Our Blog

Thanksgiving is over, turkey: When to kill your darlings

by Angie Halama on January 20th, 2010

My suburban neighborhood is pretty typical, with the exception of the 200-acre wooded park in the middle of it. I live right on the edge of the park, which means deer, ducks, pheasants, and turkeys roam near my house. And I enjoy that.

But a certain turkey has really started getting in my way. Literally. 

He often hangs out on the corner of a four-way stop. At first it was funny, like he was waiting for the bus.

Then, this weekend as I approached the stop, the turkey was in the middle of the intersection. I waited for him to cross the road (I see the joke here), but he had other ideas. He headed right for my car and proceeded to block me every time I tried to swerve around him. He was so close I couldn’t even see him until his blue head popped up over the hood and he "gobble-gobbled" at me.

It was ridiculous. And maddening. I had no idea what to do. I wasn’t about to get out of the car—turkeys are surprisingly large. And this one clearly had no fear.

I finally escaped, and then I called Animal Control, who said, and I quote, "We’re aware of the turkey."

Apparently, even the local news had heard about this traffic-stopping bird. Police hadn’t been able to catch him. They even hired a professional trapper. And guess what? His trap was stolen.

Why? Because the neighbors like the turkey. They’ve been feeding him. They think of him as their mascot. They’ve even called city hall to protest his capture. They love this turkey so much that they are willing to put up with the hazards and annoyance this turkey imposes on, well, me.

So. Do you have any turkeys on your website? Let’s discuss.

A navigation "concept"

Website navigation helps users find the information they’re looking for. Sometimes.

The Flash-powered navigation on thomasedison.org includes an impressively long list of Edison’s inventions. But it literally spirals and moves as you use it, and the font is so small it’s illegible. I want to know more about Edison, but the design is getting in my way.

Here’s another example: The tiny gray boxes at the top of the site for fashion designer Alexandre Herchcovitch may look sleek, but as unlabeled navigation they tell you absolutely nothing about the content—unless you click each one. (P.S. Incredibly loud intro music and no off button? Isn’t that against the law?)

Give me what I’m looking for
If you give me a text link, make sure that when I click I get whatever the text tells me I will.

If a "Read more" link on a "Project Management Courses" page goes to a video, that video should give information on course content. It shouldn’t just show course participants saying "hi." This is only interesting to the people in the video. 

And the video ending, showing a participant in his underwear and covered with Post-It notes, helped me decide to never sign up for these classes.

Show, don’t tell

Don’t fall victim to the "blah blah blah." Just give me the goods.

Ladder Golf site visitors are likely interested in ordering this new game or learning how it’s played. So the homepage doesn’t need all kinds of content telling them why the product is so great. Instead, move that animated banner demonstrating the game from way at the bottom of the page to the top, and give visitors what they want. 

Too much fun
If you’re looking for product information on the Beggin’ Strips dog snacks site, you’re in for some unexpected fun. Play games! Put a picture of yourself and your dog in a music video! Lots of fun—and no actual product info anywhere. Hmm. Bacon-flavored turkey? 

Why did the turkey cross the road?
I don’t care. Because it’s not funny.

Do you have turkeys on your website? No matter how fun, cute, or beautifully designed a turkey is, if it keeps users from getting to the information they want, then it’s causing an annoying, even aggravating, experience.

Think of it this way: Does anyone want a turkey getting in their way? No, they don’t. Trust me.  

 

  • jection
    I found this site today and boy am I glad I did. This segment was great and it gave me some ideas about what I could and can’t do. It was great seeing and perusing. I will keep tuned in and keep up the good work!!
    alaska cruises
  • Angie:

    I LOVE this post.

    I just finished an audit of a site recently that had plenty of its own turkey problems. The too much fun example seems to be something that is always a problem for a lot of brands. I always feel bad whenever I say to someone "sure, that sounds fun, but why do you want users to do that and what does it mean to them when they're done."

    Those types of things might be great for increasing visits, but that metric certainly doesn't mean increased sales, understanding of the product or increased brand consideration.

    Great stuff.
  • Kathy
    I whole-heartedly agree with your comments! I have graphic designers wanting so hard to make our application "pretty" they make it less-usable...degrading the overall experience. I want the application to aesthetically look great too but the "design" of the site shouldn't take away from the task at hand. Thank you!
  • Enjoying your metaphors, I'll answer your question with a look at your own blog and a simple declaration that your turkey is your left sidebar with the simple reasoning that mobile devices are forced to scroll through the jumble to reach your content. That, and the Disqus commenting system is not mobile friendly to BlackBerry devices.

    I elaborate on the above at http://ariwriter.com/how-mobile-friendly-is-you... if curious. Thanks.
  • This is a great article - love the turkey metaphor! Another good tip about "learn more" links... If you are sending someone to a video, tell them so... nothing is more embarrassing than a video starting to blare from your office because you didn't realize a link was video and you forgot to set your computer on mute. :-)
  • angiehalama
    Hey, Ben. I can't speak for what Kristina does, but I came across some of these examples while researching and writing this post, and some came up from my everyday web use.

    When I do come across sites like these, I'm likely to a.) get frustrated because I can't find what I'm looking for, and/or b.) leave the site. I don't usually bookmark them because, while I don't find them constantly, I'll probably come across another frustrating example soon!
  • bencurnett
    Wow. It says right there, at the top, "by Angie Halama". I'm usually only bad at names when I can't remember them, but I've really raised the bar here by not even reading correctly. Sheesh.

    Thanks for the info on how you went about getting these examples. It had never occurred to me to bookmark bad sites, for the reason you state. More are coming.

    But I wonder if it wouldn't be a good idea to start? It might make talking conceptually to clients easier if I had some ready examples of why we shouldn't go in the direction they're proposing.

    'Course, that could really backfire.

    Food for thought. Which is why I liked your post so much. Thanks, and sorry.
  • bencurnett
    Hi Kristina. Thanks for the post.

    Curious: Do you bookmark examples of strange/ineffective/annoying content as you find them?

    Or are they so plentiful that it's relatively easy for you to find them at will (or, more to the point, against your will)?
  • shawnshell
    *Loved* this article. I don't know that I was completely following you when you started in about the turkey, but you brought it around nicely in the end. Excellent advice for anyone responsible for a web application!
blog comments powered by Disqus